Tata Capital > Blog > Wealth Services > Are IRR and MOIC the key markers of VC funding success?
VC funding is all about investments in high-growth startups and timing the exit strategy perfectly. The measure of this is gauged with key metrics such as IRR and MOIC. With one, you get the consistency and speed of your returns, while the other gives a total and absolute measure of return.
metrics such as IRR and MOIC have helped investors and business owners to understand and measure VC funding success and returns – both as absolute and over time.
Venture Capital (VC) is a crucial source of finance in today’s entrepreneurial world. The private market ecosystem thrives on VC funding and startup investing firms, as venture capital funds create value for investors and businesses.
As value is created and returns are generated, the evaluation of VC funds is gauged with performance metrics such as Internal Rate of Return (IRR) and Multiple on Invested Capital (MOIC). To understand how VC funds generate returns, we must first understand these performance metrics and why VC funds use them.
MOIC and IRR are popular measures used to evaluate investment performance in segments such as private equity, venture capital and real estate. These are investments that take years to mature, and these metrics help us measure the absolute wealth created and the speed and efficiency of such creation. For this reason, these two metrics are avidly used by fund managers to measure VC fund performance.
IRR vs MOIC is an interesting combination, as both measure different aspects of VC fund performance.
As its name suggests, MOIC is expressed as a multiple. It gives us the absolute return on an investment, i.e., how much money has been generated out of the amount invested. Being a multiple like 2X and 3X, it is independent of time.
It is measured as,
MOIC = {Total Cash Distributions + Remaining Value} / Total Invested Capital or
MOIC= Total Value/ Initial Investment
For example, if the initial investment of a VC fund was Rs. 10 crores, and the exit value was Rs. 30 crores, the MOIC is 3X, i.e., the wealth generated was three times the invested capital. MOIC is a simple metric that highlights the total value created from an investment.
Unlike MOIC, IRR is a rate and not a multiple. It considers the time taken to generate returns and gives the annualized rate of return on an investment. It measures how quickly an investment has compounded, and accounts for the time value of money.
Two investments with the same MOIC can have very different IRRs. Consider the table below,
| Investment | MOIC | Holding Period |
| Startup A | 3X | 3 years |
| Startup B | 3X | 8 years |
Given the shorter time taken to generate an MOIC of 3X, Startup A will have a better IRR than Startup B.
MOIC and IRR are complementary metrics, and one cannot replace the other. For investors, MOIC provides a measure of,
With IRR, investors gain an understanding of,
For a complete assessment of venture fund performance, professional investors evaluate IRR in conjunction with MOIC. Entrepreneurs seeking capital also benefit from understanding these metrics. It helps them understand the meaning of VC funding measures and engage in a meaningful conversation with investors.
The merit of a VC investment lies in the profitability prospects of a startup. The startup has to deliver handsome returns within a reasonable time. To do so, it has to display scalability and the opportunity of a profitable exit. These can be measured conclusively using metrics like MOIC and IRR, and influence how VC funding works.
As you gain understanding of the metrics, it is also important to understand the bigger picture, which is how a VC fund works. A VC fund pools money from investors, and the fund manager invests it with the expectation of high returns from the investments.
The success of this entire operation is measured with the help of metrics, with IRR and MOIC being the prominent ones.
Understanding metrics like MOIC and IRR helps us understand how investors assess their VC performance. In this regard, IRR and MOIC are particularly relevant in India’s expanding startup ecosystem. They will help investors and entrepreneurs understand how VC funds in India measure funding success and failure.
It is the ecosystem where VC firms make equity investments in startups and promising high-growth businesses in India.
Entrepreneurs and startup founders approach VC firms through networking events, accelerator programs, startup platforms or a direct approach, almost always with a strong pitch deck.
How to start a VC fund in India is something that can be considered with investment expertise, compliance, fundraising capacity and strategy. An investment management structure should be in place, which complies with the regulations applicable to private investment vehicles.
VC investors generally seek an annualized IRR of 30% at the early stage. This expectation may be lower in later-stage and growth equity investments, typically 20 - 25%.
Top VC funds in India are known to share IRR and MOIC information with their limited partners. However, detailed fund-level performance information may not be made public.